Uzma Khatoon

Islamic feminism is essential for Muslim societies for various reasons. It challenges patriarchal interpretations of the Quran and Hadith, advocating a woman-friendly perspective. Central to Islamic feminism is the need to promote gender equality as a fundamental aspect of Islam, reviving the egalitarian principles inherent in the religion right from its inception.

This movement addresses and counters the misconceptions that gender discrimination is an intrinsic part of Islam. It argues that such inequalities are coined by humans and not mandated by the divine. By emphasizing legal and social reforms, Islamic feminists push for changes in family laws and social rights and bring about key legal changes in countries like Iran and Morocco.

Moreover, it provides a culturally relevant framework for addressing women's rights within Muslim societies, effectively distinguishing between faith and cultural practices.

Islamic feminism has emerged as a crucial movement within the broader feminist discourse seeking to reclaim and reinforce the egalitarian principles embedded within Islamic teachings. Prominent Islamic feminist scholars, such as Asma Barlas and Amina Wadud, adopt a hermeneutical approach to the Quran, focusing on the ethical worldview present in the text.

They contend that the core ethical principles of the Quran, including tawhid (the oneness of God) and taqwa (God-consciousness), serve as foundational elements for advancing gender justice. Islamic feminism has the potential to deconstruct patriarchal interpretations of the Quran and provide alternative readings that advocate equality and social justice.

The roots of Islamic feminism can be traced back to the early 20th century when Muslim women began demanding greater rights and representation within their societies. It was not merely a reaction to Western feminist movements; it represented an effort to return to the egalitarian spirit of the Quran. Early reformers, such as Fatima Mernissi, criticized the ways patriarchal structures distorted Islamic teachings to sustain male dominance.

Today, Islamic feminism continues this tradition, engaging critically with both classical Islamic scholarship and modern feminist theories. Unlike secular feminists critiquing Islam as inherently patriarchal, Islamic feminists work from within the tradition to challenge oppressive interpretations and assert that many misogynistic readings of Islamic law stem from patriarchal influences rather than the religion itself.

At the heart of Islamic feminism is the ethical framework established by the Quran. Scholars like Barlas and Wadud argue that the Quran promotes justice, equality, and human dignity—principles that are essential to achieving gender justice. This ethical focus allows Islamic feminists to critique traditional interpretations of the Quran that have historically marginalized women and perpetuated patriarchal norms.

A key concept in this ethical framework is tawhid, the belief in the oneness of God. Barlas posits that this belief entails that no human has the right to assert dominance over another based on gender, race, or class. Therefore, patriarchy, which seeks to maintain male sovereignty over women, directly contradicts the principle of tawhid. This understanding offers a theological basis for gender equality, asserting that all human beings are equal in their relationship with God.

Taqwa, or God-consciousness, further reinforces the ethical principles that Islamic feminists employ to advocate for gender justice. The Quran states that the only criterion for superiority among individuals is taqwa (Q. 49:13), which is accessible to all, irrespective of gender. This egalitarian message is pivotal to the feminist mission of uncovering the ethical possibilities within the Quran to achieve gender justice.

Islamic feminist scholars endeavor to deconstruct the patriarchal interpretations of the Quran and Islamic tradition that have historically justified the subordination of women. They critique classical jurists who, while recognizing the ethical messages in the Quran, often fail to apply these principles consistently when formulating legal rulings on gender issues.

For instance, marriage and divorce laws in classical Islamic jurisprudence frequently privilege men, despite the Quran’s emphasis on justice and fairness in these matters. Barlas argues that many classical interpretations of the Quran are shaped by the socio-political contexts of their times, which were predominantly patriarchal. These interpretations are not immutable and can be reassessed in light of the Quran’s broader ethical principles. By adopting a hermeneutic of justice, Islamic feminists seek to reveal more egalitarian readings of the text that can serve as the basis for legal reforms and social transformation.

Wadud advocates for a holistic approach to interpreting the Quran that prioritizes the ethical and moral intent of the text over its literal meanings. This approach fosters a more dynamic engagement with the Quran, allowing its ethical principles to be applied to contemporary issues, including those related to gender. For Wadud, the aim is not solely to interpret the text but to actualize its ethical imperatives in ways that promote justice and equality.

A primary objective of Islamic feminism is to facilitate legal reform and social transformation. Many Muslim-majority countries have legal systems grounded, at least in part, in Islamic law. However, these laws often reflect patriarchal interpretations of the Quran and Islamic tradition. Islamic feminists contend that these laws must be reformed under the ethical principles espoused by the Quran, which advocates for justice and equality for all individuals. For example, Islamic feminists challenge laws regarding marriage, divorce, and inheritance that typically disadvantage women.

In numerous countries, men possess greater rights in marriage and divorce proceedings, while women face significant limitations in their ability to initiate divorce or claim equal inheritance. Islamic feminists assert that these legal frameworks are misaligned with the Quran’s emphasis on justice and fairness. They advocate for reforms that ensure greater equality for women within the legal system.

Social transformation is equally vital to the goals of Islamic feminism. By challenging patriarchal norms and championing gender justice, Islamic feminists strive to create more egalitarian societies where women can fully participate in all life aspects. This endeavor encompasses not only legal reforms but also shifts in cultural attitudes and practices that have historically marginalized women. The movement aims to reshape societal perceptions of gender roles, fostering an environment that empowers women and promotes their active participation in decision-making processes across various spheres of life.

Despite its potential for fostering gender justice, Islamic feminism confronts substantial challenges. Critics argue that Islam and feminism are inherently incompatible, asserting that feminism is a Western construct devoid of relevance in Islamic societies. Others reject Islamic feminism because it imposes contemporary notions of equality onto the Quran without adequately engaging with the text's intrinsic principles.

Yasmin Moll critiques Islamic feminists for adopting modern hermeneutic theories while invoking the authority of the Islamic tradition without a profound understanding of its methodologies. She argues that Islamic feminist scholarship often lacks the rigorous engagement with the classical tradition necessary to bolster its critiques.

Additionally, critics like Aysha Hidayatullah challenge the foundational premise of Islamic feminism, which asserts that gender equality is a fundamental tenet of the Quran. Hidayatullah contends that the Quran contains both egalitarian and hierarchical messages regarding gender, and Islamic feminists must confront the tension between these messages rather than presuming that the Quran unequivocally endorses gender equality. This critical examination of the Quran’s multifaceted nature is crucial for developing a comprehensive understanding of gender relations within the Islamic framework.

Despite these challenges, there is an urgent need for 'Islamic feminism.'. It serves as a vital movement for advancing gender justice within Muslim communities by critically engaging with the Quran and Islamic tradition. Through this engagement, Islamic feminists aim to uncover ethical principles that support gender equality while challenging the patriarchal interpretations that have historically marginalized women. Their efforts extend beyond mere interpretation; they strive to reform legal systems and transform societal norms to cultivate environments where justice and equality prevail.

As the discourse surrounding Islamic feminism continues to evolve, its emphasis on the ethical worldview of the Quran and commitment to working within the Islamic tradition positions it as a powerful force for change. With the ongoing engagement of Muslim women with these ideas, Islamic feminism is likely to grow, contributing significantly to the global conversation on gender justice. This movement does not seek to dismantle Islam but rather to illuminate its inherent values of justice and equality, thus facilitating a transformative dialogue that resonates within Muslim societies and beyond.

ALSO READ: My work is ibadat; Dr Shahana AK, Ayurvedic para-surgery expert

The need for Islamic feminism in Muslim societies cannot be overstated. It is a movement rooted in the quest for justice, equality, and a revaluation of the Quran and Hadith in light of contemporary challenges. By providing a platform for women’s voices and perspectives, Islamic feminism is essential for fostering a more equitable and just society, aligning with the original teachings of Islam. As we navigate the complexities of modern life, the call for Islamic feminism serves as a reminder of the importance of inclusivity and equity within the Muslim community, ultimately benefiting all of society.

Dr. Uzma Khatoon is a former teacher at the Aligarh Muslim University.