Eman Sakina

Economic systems play a crucial role in shaping societies' socio-economic structure. The Islamic economic system and socialism are pioneer models for society. While both systems aim to address economic disparities and promote social welfare, they differ significantly in their foundations, principles, and implementation.

Friday Musings

Islam recognizes that humans must undertake various economic activities to survive in a competitive society with limited resources. It also observes that economic science and economic systems enable human beings to satisfy their needs. The economic science, which involves the production of goods and services, is the same irrespective of religion or geographical location. Comparatively, the economic system determines the distribution of resources and is of great interest to Islam (Quran 149). Therefore, Shari’ah (Islamic law) provides a means of acquiring, disposing, and distributing wealth.

The economic system of a society is important in Islam because it determines the distribution of resources, thus contributing to the occurrence of poverty. It is through an economic system that a society can influence the distribution of resources and alleviate poverty. The scarce resources in society follow laws of demand and supply in their distribution, which are under the influence of an economic system such as socialism and capitalism.

With equal distribution of wealth in society, everybody has equal opportunities to access wealth and progress.

As Islam recognizes that humans survive through economic activities, the Islamic economic system does not discourage an individual from acquiring resources. Lawful acquisition of wealth is holy as the Quran says that Allah bestows blessings on people who work hard in their labor.

Islam does not allow people to indulge in corruption as a means of satisfying their daily bread needs.

All manners of expenditure that cause harm to individuals or society are immoral according to the Islamic economic system. Islam holds that the most desirable way of spending legally acquired wealth is by satisfying reasonable needs and saving others for the sake of other people in society (Quran 137)

In the Islamic economic system, private ownership is recognized and protected, provided it aligns with ethical guidelines and does not harm society. However, Islam imposes obligations such as Zakat (charitable tax) to redistribute wealth. Socialism, on the other hand, advocates collective ownership of major resources and industries, with limited room for private property.

Islam emphasizes balanced wealth distribution through traditions like Zakat, Sadaqah (voluntary charity), and inheritance laws. It discourages hoarding and monopolies while promoting economic justice. Socialism seeks equality through state-controlled distribution of wealth, often through taxation and nationalization of resources.

Islamic economics encourages productivity and innovation through personal ownership and ethical entrepreneurship, driven by material and spiritual rewards. In socialism, individual motivation can be limited due to the absence of personal ownership incentives, leading to inefficiency and a lack of creativity.

The Islamic economic system emphasizes ethical behavior, transparency, and accountability, considering economic activities as part of worship. Socialism, while promoting social equality, often lacks a spiritual or moral foundation, relying primarily on regulatory enforcement.

ALSO READ: Manmohan Singh's ancestral village in Pakistan mired in backwardness